A crowded Instagram following list can be tedious to review. Meta’s AI assistant Muse has made it easier for some users to find accounts that do not follow them back—and, for some, to turn that information into a round of unfollows. The tool has revived an old question about social media etiquette: does following someone imply a relationship or an expectation of reciprocity?
A quick way to check who follows back
Khalil Roberts had heard that third-party apps used to remove followers could get Instagram accounts flagged as spam. So when he saw a post on X claiming Muse could identify people who did not follow him back, he was initially skeptical. He had wondered about his own list, though, and the possibility of using Muse changed his mind.
Roberts asked the assistant to find non-celebrities who did not follow him back and unfollow them. He had over 7,600 followers. Within minutes, Muse identified 151 accounts and organized them in an Excel sheet with usernames, real names, classifications and profile links. It then asked whether he wanted to proceed.
Some accounts belonged to people Roberts had thought of as friends. He said the result was surprising, but also a reminder that they no longer had a relationship. After his November 7 cleanup, he shared instructions on X. In the following weeks, users on X, Instagram and Facebook posted about using Muse to automate unfollows.
Reciprocity becomes a rule
For some users, the appeal is straightforward: why follow someone who does not follow you? Replies to posts about the trend included comments about reciprocity and users celebrating a freshly cleaned-up list. One person posted, “Just unfollowed 1000+ people on IG.”
Tech worker Kimberly Munoz, who has 33,200 Instagram followers, said she did not want to be “anybody’s fan.” In an Instagram video, she described using the feature to look for people she knew in real life who had unfollowed her. Another user said they had downloaded Muse specifically for that purpose.
But a follow can mean different things to different people. It may signal friendship, make it easier to keep up with a crush, or simply reflect a social expectation that following should go both ways. With no shared etiquette, a list of accounts can feel to one person like practical housekeeping and to another like evidence about a relationship.
When information changes how people feel
Natalie Pennington, an associate professor who researches social connection at Colorado State University, raised a concern about turning small social decisions over to technology. Finding out who does not follow back may save time, but the information can also make an emotionally uncomfortable choice harder to avoid.
Pennington also questioned whether users need to know this at all. A platform can surface information that might otherwise take effort to find, but the ease of access does not make it useful. Once someone sees a name on a list, they may feel pushed to interpret the absence of a follow—even though the list itself cannot explain why another person made that choice.
In October, Meta removed an advertising campaign that promoted Muse with the promise that users could “see who unfollowed you each week,” Business Insider reported. Meta did not respond to WIRED’s request for comment about why the ad was removed.
Cleaning a feed without handing over the decision
Some users have turned to Muse for a less personal reason: reducing a feed that has become cluttered over time. Elizabeth Brooks, a self-described “sweeper” who enters sweepstakes and promotional contests, had followed giveaway accounts for 10 years. She began asking Muse to provide five profile links every few hours, up to six times a day, then manually unfollowing accounts one at a time.
That approach treats Muse as a way to find candidates, while leaving the choice to the user. Roberts, who joined Instagram in high school 15 years ago and calls it “my app of choice,” said people are becoming more intentional about who they allow into their online lives. Still, he does not plan to let Muse make further decisions about his social life. As he put it, “Unfollowing is where I draw the line.”